Research Article
BibTex RIS Cite

İsrail Ordusunda Dürzi Askerlerin Statüsü ve Hak İhlalleri

Year 2025, Issue: 18, 234 - 252, 31.12.2025
https://doi.org/10.34230/fiad.1753399

Abstract

7 Ekim 2023 tarihinde Hamas tarafından İsrail işgaline karşı başlatılan “Aksa Tufanı” operasyonunun uluslararası gündemde yer almasıyla birlikte, İsrail’in bölgedeki ihlalleri sorgulanmaya başlanmıştır. Ancak yaşanan katliamları yalnızca İsrail-Filistin çatışması üzerinden değerlendirmek eksik bir yaklaşım olacaktır; bu bağlamda İsrail içindeki iç dinamiklere, özellikle de ülkenin sosyal ve askeri politikalarında kritik rol oynayan Dürzi toplumuna odaklanmak gerekmektedir. Bu çalışma, İsrail vatandaşı olan Dürzilerin askeri ve sosyal durumlarını, ordu içindeki statüleri ve karşılaştıkları hak ihlalleri ekseninde ele almaktadır. İsrail, kuruluşundan itibaren benimsediği etnik temelli ulus-devlet anlayışını, 2018 tarihli “Yahudi Ulus Devleti Yasası” ile anayasal bir çerçeveye oturtmuştur. Bu yasa, devlete sadakat temelinde entegre olmuş Dürzilerin statüsünü zayıflatarak onları “vatansız vatandaş” kimliğine sürüklemiştir. Siyonist zihniyet, bir sömürge mekanizması olarak Dürzi tarihini yeniden kurgulamış, topluluğu Yahudilikle bağlantılandırarak diğer Araplardan ayrıştırmayı hedeflemiştir. Özellikle İsrail ordusunda (IDF) görev alan Dürzi askerler, Batı Şeria ve Gazze’deki ev baskınlarında, kontrol noktalarındaki sert uygulamalarda ve hapishanelerdeki Filistinli tutuklulara yönelik baskı süreçlerinde görevlendirilerek Siyonist politikalara hizmet etmek zorunda bırakılmıştır. Bu strateji, İsrail’in Dürziler ile Filistinliler arasında bilinçli bir uçurum ve düşmanlık yaratma politikasının somut bir göstergesidir. Çalışma, İsrail’in “sadık azınlık” söyleminin Dürzi toplumuna eşit yurttaşlık hakları sağlamadığını; aksine demokrasi ile etno-milliyetçi yapı arasındaki gerilimin kurbanı olduklarını ortaya koymaktadır. Yerel kalkınma, bütçe dağılımı ve imar sorunları gibi yapısal eşitsizlikler, uzun vadede “Dürzilerin İsrailleştirilmesi” projesinin geçerliliğini yitirmesine neden olmaktadır. Nitekim Dürzilerin devletle kurdukları tarihsel sadakatin yanında, giderek daha güçlü dile getirilen eşitlik ve tanınma talepleri arasında sıkışmış çok katmanlı bir toplumsal konumda durdukları görülmektedir. Sonuç olarak bu araştırma, İsrail’in “kimliksizleştirme” politikasıyla karşı karşıya kalan Dürzilerin, hem devletin güvenlik politikalarındaki araçsallaştırılmış rollerini hem de yaşadıkları aidiyet krizini ve iki devletli çözüm arayışlarını detaylandıracaktır.

References

  • Al Jarmaq, “Tecnid Evvel Şabbe Dürziyye fi Ceyşi’l İsraili”, (24 Eylül 2023), https://l24.im/nsa8
  • Aridi, Naim. The Druze in Israel: History, Overview. Jewish Virtual Library. (Erişim 25 Ocak 2025) https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/history-and-overview-of-the-israeli-druze
  • Armaoğlu, Fahir. Filistin Meselesi ve Arap - İsrail Savaşları (Ciltli): (1948-1988). İstanbul: Kronik Kitap, 2017.
  • Atashi, Zeidan. The Druze In Israel And The Question Of Compulsory Military Service. Jerusalem Letter. (Erişim 27 Ocak 2025) https://jcpa.org/jl/vp464.htm
  • Bağlıoğlu, Ahmet. İnanç Esasları Açısından Dürzilik. Ankara: Ankara Okulu, 2004.
  • Carrie, Keller Lynn, “Coalition promises Basic Law to enshrine status of Druze, won’t nix controversial law, The Times of Jerusalem. (Erişim 28 Mayıs 2025) https://www.timesofisrael.com/coalition-promises-basic-law-to-enshrine-status-of-druze-wont-nix-controversial-law/
  • Cerrar, Mervan Ferid, “Sukna Düruz fi Filistin”, Mecelle el Camia el İslamiyye, 19/2 (2011): 1279-1314.
  • Cerrar, Mervan Ferid, “Alakatü’l Yahudiyye ed-Dürziyye fi Filistin fi Fetreti’l İntidabi’l Britani (1918-1948)”, Mecelle el Camiatü’l Kuds el Meftuha 21 (2010): 299-344.
  • Chaska, Katz, “December 2017 Demolition and Displacement report”, (Erişim 25 Şubat 2025) https://icahd.org/2018/01/15/december-2017-demolition-displacement-report/
  • Eldar, Doron, Young, Gay. The ‘Nation-State Law’ and non-Jews belonging in Israel: Druze loyalty, citizenship and positionality in the Jewish state. Nations and Nationalism, 30/4, (2024), 666–682.
  • Erkan, Ümit; “Tarihten günümüze Filistin ve Dürziler”. Geçmişten Günümüze Filistin. Ed. Tuğba Velioğlu, Faruk Narmanlı, Mahmoud Bernas, Ensar Neşriyat. İstanbul: 2024.
  • Epstein, Eliahu, “The Druzes of Palestine”, Journal of The Royal Central Asian Society, 29:1, (2011): 52-63.
  • Eugene L. Rogan; Avi Shlaim (2001). The War for Palestine: Rewriting the History of 1948 (illustrated, reprint ed.). Cambridge University Press.
  • FDD Flash Brief. Israeli Druze Colonel Killed in Gaza Fighting. FDD. (Erişim 20 Aralık 2024). https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2023/11/02/israeli-druze-colonel-killed-in-gaza-fighting/
  • Firro, Kais. A history of The Druzes. Leiden; New York: E.J. Brill, 1992.
  • Maysan Hamdan, Tecnid el İcbari ve’l cender fi’l müctemaati’d-Dürziyye tahte’l İhtilal, Kohl: Mecelle el Ebhas el Cesed ve’l Cender, 2/1, (2016). 41-47.
  • Kais Firro. Druzes in the Jewish State. Leiden; New York: E.J. Brill, 1999.
  • Hazran, Yusri. The Druze in Israel: A Silent Minority Begins to Speak Out. The Jerusalem Strategic Tribune. (Erişim 25 Ocak 2025) https://jstribune.com/hazran-the-druze-in-israel/ adresinden erişildi.
  • Hemarşa, Heba. “Keyfe Nefhem Hidmet el Düruz ve’l Bedv fi’l Ceyş’il İsraili”, Megazine, (Erişim 25 Nisan 2025), https://l24.im/5fiZPC
  • Jerusalem Post Staff. Israel’s Druze sector threatens to cut ties with IDF after young woman drafted. The Jerusalem Post. (Erişim 14 Aralık 2024) https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-760186 adresinden erişildi.
  • Inter-Agency Task Force On Israeli Arab Issues. Druze In Israel Issue Brief. (Erişim 26 Ocak 2025) https://www.iataskforce.org/resources/view/1558
  • “Interior Ministry delays powder-keg Druze home demolitions”, The Times of Israel, (Erişim 20 Şubat 2025) https://www.timesofisrael.com/interior-ministry-delays-powder-keg-druze-home-demolitions/
  • Khaizran, Yusri. “The Druze in Israel: Between Protest and Containment,” Jerusalem Quarterly 96 (2023): 8–27
  • Kolirin, Lianne. Israel’s Druze Arabs, fiercely loyal to the state, feel let down after ‘paying with their blood’. CNN. (Erişim 21 Şubat 2025) https://edition.cnn.com/2024/02/21/middleeast/israels-druze-loyal-state-intl-scli/index.html
  • Okuduci, İdris. “Lebanese Druze leader calls on Israeli Druze not to take part in war, Anadolu Agency ( Erişim 24 Ocak 2025) https://www.aa.com.tr/en/middle-east/lebanese-druze-leader-calls-on-israeli-druze-not-to-take-part-in-war/3012003
  • Makarem, Sami Nasib. The Druze Faith. N.Y: Caravan Books, Delmar, 1979.
  • Muhsin, M. “Düruz Filistin Yerfudun et-Tecnid el- İsraili”, Al Jazeera, (Erişim 25 Şubat 2025). https://l24.im/ofG7cNK
  • Pileggi, Tamar. Druze leaders warn order to raze homes could spark violence. The Times Of Israel. (Erişim 17 Aralık 2024) https://www.timesofisrael.com/druze-leaders-warn-order-to-raze-homes-could-spark-violence/
  • Sommer, Allison Kaplan. The Druze Community in Israel, Explained. Haaretz. (Erişim 24 Ocak 2024) https://www.haaretz.com/haaretz-explains/2023-06-11/ty-article/.premium/the-druze-community-in-israel-explained/00000188-8c42-d3c4-afec-9ed397020000
  • Sydney, Elizabeth Green, “The Israeli Druze: “Neither Here Nor There”, (The University of Mississippi, 2018)
  • Stolk, Babette Helena. Political Disillusionment Is Growing in Israel’s Druze Community. News Line Magazine. (Erişim 25 Ocak 2025) https://newlinesmag.com/reportage/political-disillusionment-is-growing-in-israels-druze-community/
  • The Lebanese Constitution, Promulgated May 23, 1926 With Its Amendments, 1995
  • Theodorou, A. E. 5 Facts About Israeli Druze, A Unique Religious And Ethnic Group. Pew Research Center. (Erişim 24 Ocak 2025) https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2016/03/21/5-facts-about-israeli-druze-a-unique-religious-and-ethnic-group/#:~:text=In%20Israel%2C%20the%20Druze%20are,Carmel%20and%20the%20Golan%20Heights
  • Yıldız, Tuba. Geleneğin Hukuku Osmanlı’nın Adaleti: Dürziler ve Maruniler. İstanbul: Vadi Yayınları, 2020.
  • Yıldız, Tuba. “Devletçe İslam”: Birinci Dünya Savaşı’nda Dürziler ve Hukuki Statüleri. Tarih Dergisi 78 , (2022), 101-122.
  • “100 Dubbad Kebir fi’l Ceyşi’l İsraili Yendammune ila Mariketi Dıdda Kanunu’l Kavmiyye.” Aawsat. (Erişim 15 Şubat 2025) https://tls.tc/YZnJH
  • Zeedan, Rami. The Role of Military Service in the Integration/Segregation of Muslims, Christians and Druze within Israel. Societies, 9/ 1 (2019), 1-15.

The Status of Druze Soldiers in The Israeli Army and Human Rights Violations

Year 2025, Issue: 18, 234 - 252, 31.12.2025
https://doi.org/10.34230/fiad.1753399

Abstract

Following the placement of Operation "Al-Aqsa Flood," launched by Hamas against the Israeli occupation on October 7, 2023, on the international agenda, Israel’s violations in the region have come under scrutiny. However, evaluating the ensuing massacres solely through the lens of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict reveals an incomplete approach; in this context, it is necessary to focus on internal dynamics within Israel, particularly the Druze community, which plays a critical role in the country's social and military policies. This study examines the military and social status of Druze citizens of Israel, focusing on their standing within the army and the rights violations they encounter. Israel has codified its ethnic-based nation-state concept, adopted since its foundation, into a constitutional framework via the 2018 "Jewish Nation-State Law." This legislation has undermined the status of the Druze, who were integrated based on loyalty to the state, thereby relegating them to the identity of "stateless citizens." The Zionist mentality has reconstructed Druze history as a colonial mechanism, aiming to dissociate the community from other Arabs by forging a connection with Judaism. Specifically, Druze soldiers serving in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) have been compelled to serve Zionist policies by being deployed for home raids in the West Bank and Gaza, harsh enforcement at checkpoints, and oppressive measures against Palestinian detainees in prisons. This strategy serves as a concrete manifestation of Israel's policy to intentionally create a rift and hostility between the Druze and Palestinians. The study reveals that Israel's "loyal minority" discourse has not granted equal citizenship rights to the Druze community; on the contrary, they have become victims of the tension between democracy and the ethno-nationalist structure. Structural inequalities regarding local development, budget distribution, and zoning issues are causing the "Israelization of the Druze" project to lose its validity in the long run. Indeed, the Druze are situated in a multi-layered social position, caught between their historical loyalty to the state and increasingly vocal demands for equality and recognition. Ultimately, this research details the instrumentalized roles of the Druze within state security policies, their ensuing identity crisis, and their pursuit of a two-state solution in the face of Israel's policy of "de-identification”.

References

  • Al Jarmaq, “Tecnid Evvel Şabbe Dürziyye fi Ceyşi’l İsraili”, (24 Eylül 2023), https://l24.im/nsa8
  • Aridi, Naim. The Druze in Israel: History, Overview. Jewish Virtual Library. (Erişim 25 Ocak 2025) https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/history-and-overview-of-the-israeli-druze
  • Armaoğlu, Fahir. Filistin Meselesi ve Arap - İsrail Savaşları (Ciltli): (1948-1988). İstanbul: Kronik Kitap, 2017.
  • Atashi, Zeidan. The Druze In Israel And The Question Of Compulsory Military Service. Jerusalem Letter. (Erişim 27 Ocak 2025) https://jcpa.org/jl/vp464.htm
  • Bağlıoğlu, Ahmet. İnanç Esasları Açısından Dürzilik. Ankara: Ankara Okulu, 2004.
  • Carrie, Keller Lynn, “Coalition promises Basic Law to enshrine status of Druze, won’t nix controversial law, The Times of Jerusalem. (Erişim 28 Mayıs 2025) https://www.timesofisrael.com/coalition-promises-basic-law-to-enshrine-status-of-druze-wont-nix-controversial-law/
  • Cerrar, Mervan Ferid, “Sukna Düruz fi Filistin”, Mecelle el Camia el İslamiyye, 19/2 (2011): 1279-1314.
  • Cerrar, Mervan Ferid, “Alakatü’l Yahudiyye ed-Dürziyye fi Filistin fi Fetreti’l İntidabi’l Britani (1918-1948)”, Mecelle el Camiatü’l Kuds el Meftuha 21 (2010): 299-344.
  • Chaska, Katz, “December 2017 Demolition and Displacement report”, (Erişim 25 Şubat 2025) https://icahd.org/2018/01/15/december-2017-demolition-displacement-report/
  • Eldar, Doron, Young, Gay. The ‘Nation-State Law’ and non-Jews belonging in Israel: Druze loyalty, citizenship and positionality in the Jewish state. Nations and Nationalism, 30/4, (2024), 666–682.
  • Erkan, Ümit; “Tarihten günümüze Filistin ve Dürziler”. Geçmişten Günümüze Filistin. Ed. Tuğba Velioğlu, Faruk Narmanlı, Mahmoud Bernas, Ensar Neşriyat. İstanbul: 2024.
  • Epstein, Eliahu, “The Druzes of Palestine”, Journal of The Royal Central Asian Society, 29:1, (2011): 52-63.
  • Eugene L. Rogan; Avi Shlaim (2001). The War for Palestine: Rewriting the History of 1948 (illustrated, reprint ed.). Cambridge University Press.
  • FDD Flash Brief. Israeli Druze Colonel Killed in Gaza Fighting. FDD. (Erişim 20 Aralık 2024). https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2023/11/02/israeli-druze-colonel-killed-in-gaza-fighting/
  • Firro, Kais. A history of The Druzes. Leiden; New York: E.J. Brill, 1992.
  • Maysan Hamdan, Tecnid el İcbari ve’l cender fi’l müctemaati’d-Dürziyye tahte’l İhtilal, Kohl: Mecelle el Ebhas el Cesed ve’l Cender, 2/1, (2016). 41-47.
  • Kais Firro. Druzes in the Jewish State. Leiden; New York: E.J. Brill, 1999.
  • Hazran, Yusri. The Druze in Israel: A Silent Minority Begins to Speak Out. The Jerusalem Strategic Tribune. (Erişim 25 Ocak 2025) https://jstribune.com/hazran-the-druze-in-israel/ adresinden erişildi.
  • Hemarşa, Heba. “Keyfe Nefhem Hidmet el Düruz ve’l Bedv fi’l Ceyş’il İsraili”, Megazine, (Erişim 25 Nisan 2025), https://l24.im/5fiZPC
  • Jerusalem Post Staff. Israel’s Druze sector threatens to cut ties with IDF after young woman drafted. The Jerusalem Post. (Erişim 14 Aralık 2024) https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-760186 adresinden erişildi.
  • Inter-Agency Task Force On Israeli Arab Issues. Druze In Israel Issue Brief. (Erişim 26 Ocak 2025) https://www.iataskforce.org/resources/view/1558
  • “Interior Ministry delays powder-keg Druze home demolitions”, The Times of Israel, (Erişim 20 Şubat 2025) https://www.timesofisrael.com/interior-ministry-delays-powder-keg-druze-home-demolitions/
  • Khaizran, Yusri. “The Druze in Israel: Between Protest and Containment,” Jerusalem Quarterly 96 (2023): 8–27
  • Kolirin, Lianne. Israel’s Druze Arabs, fiercely loyal to the state, feel let down after ‘paying with their blood’. CNN. (Erişim 21 Şubat 2025) https://edition.cnn.com/2024/02/21/middleeast/israels-druze-loyal-state-intl-scli/index.html
  • Okuduci, İdris. “Lebanese Druze leader calls on Israeli Druze not to take part in war, Anadolu Agency ( Erişim 24 Ocak 2025) https://www.aa.com.tr/en/middle-east/lebanese-druze-leader-calls-on-israeli-druze-not-to-take-part-in-war/3012003
  • Makarem, Sami Nasib. The Druze Faith. N.Y: Caravan Books, Delmar, 1979.
  • Muhsin, M. “Düruz Filistin Yerfudun et-Tecnid el- İsraili”, Al Jazeera, (Erişim 25 Şubat 2025). https://l24.im/ofG7cNK
  • Pileggi, Tamar. Druze leaders warn order to raze homes could spark violence. The Times Of Israel. (Erişim 17 Aralık 2024) https://www.timesofisrael.com/druze-leaders-warn-order-to-raze-homes-could-spark-violence/
  • Sommer, Allison Kaplan. The Druze Community in Israel, Explained. Haaretz. (Erişim 24 Ocak 2024) https://www.haaretz.com/haaretz-explains/2023-06-11/ty-article/.premium/the-druze-community-in-israel-explained/00000188-8c42-d3c4-afec-9ed397020000
  • Sydney, Elizabeth Green, “The Israeli Druze: “Neither Here Nor There”, (The University of Mississippi, 2018)
  • Stolk, Babette Helena. Political Disillusionment Is Growing in Israel’s Druze Community. News Line Magazine. (Erişim 25 Ocak 2025) https://newlinesmag.com/reportage/political-disillusionment-is-growing-in-israels-druze-community/
  • The Lebanese Constitution, Promulgated May 23, 1926 With Its Amendments, 1995
  • Theodorou, A. E. 5 Facts About Israeli Druze, A Unique Religious And Ethnic Group. Pew Research Center. (Erişim 24 Ocak 2025) https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2016/03/21/5-facts-about-israeli-druze-a-unique-religious-and-ethnic-group/#:~:text=In%20Israel%2C%20the%20Druze%20are,Carmel%20and%20the%20Golan%20Heights
  • Yıldız, Tuba. Geleneğin Hukuku Osmanlı’nın Adaleti: Dürziler ve Maruniler. İstanbul: Vadi Yayınları, 2020.
  • Yıldız, Tuba. “Devletçe İslam”: Birinci Dünya Savaşı’nda Dürziler ve Hukuki Statüleri. Tarih Dergisi 78 , (2022), 101-122.
  • “100 Dubbad Kebir fi’l Ceyşi’l İsraili Yendammune ila Mariketi Dıdda Kanunu’l Kavmiyye.” Aawsat. (Erişim 15 Şubat 2025) https://tls.tc/YZnJH
  • Zeedan, Rami. The Role of Military Service in the Integration/Segregation of Muslims, Christians and Druze within Israel. Societies, 9/ 1 (2019), 1-15.
There are 37 citations in total.

Details

Primary Language Turkish
Subjects Middle East Studies
Journal Section Research Article
Authors

Tuba Yıldız 0000-0002-7152-4421

Submission Date July 29, 2025
Acceptance Date December 26, 2025
Publication Date December 31, 2025
Published in Issue Year 2025 Issue: 18

Cite

Chicago Yıldız, Tuba. “İsrail Ordusunda Dürzi Askerlerin Statüsü Ve Hak İhlalleri”. Filistin Araştırmaları Dergisi, no. 18 (December 2025): 234-52. https://doi.org/10.34230/fiad.1753399.

 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International LicenseClick for more information.

Indexes / Databases: SCOPUS| EBSCO| INDEX ISLAMICUS| MLA | INDEX COPERNICUS | CEEOL | SCIENTIFIC INDEXING | DRJI | İSAM | ASOS İNDEKS

Filistin Araştırmaları Dergisi- FAD

[Bulletin of Palestine Studies]

[כתב העת ללימודים פלסטיניים]

[مجلة دراسات فلسطينية ]

ISSN: 2587-2532

E-ISSN 2587-1862 

www.filistin.org